• Admin @ mtgzone.com, a Magic: the Gathering community
  • More at andrewgioia.com
  • Playing and collecting MTG since Mirage!
  • I ♥️ Legacy Lands, Premodern Parfait Oath, Modern Amulet Titan, and elf tribal

  • 209 Posts
  • 339 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 9th, 2023

help-circle


















  • Andrew@mtgzone.comMtoMTG@mtgzone.comBrawl: Our Plans
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 month ago

    it is now clearly MTG Arena’s second most played format

    This is shocking to me, it really goes to show just how big a share commander formats have in the entire game. I wonder if this is just in relation to constructed formats or if they’re also including all draft formats in that too?







  • I find this to be a pretty crappy argument and outcome. Essentially it’s a lame duck standard with Vivi completely warping the format for 2 months because we need to “think of the RCQ players.” Doesn’t even acknowledge how many will not play an RCQ because of this crappy meta.

    So play Vivi or anti-Vivi the next few months (or get destroyed) then replace your deck when Vivi eats an all but certain ban. Great plan.

    I find it more alarming that they’re doubling down on the overall ban strategy. While they plan to add a few more times during the year, they’re still dodging the real issue. They won’t acknowledge that turbo charging cards over 18 sets in a standard window will require (quite a few) emergency bans!





  • I kinda like the 2-picks-per-pack as it can be easier to get into an archetype or cut something off, I have to think this is more related to 8-man pods failing to fire at LGSes though. I don’t have any data but anecdotally it seems like tabletop drafting is down and maybe this is WotC’s attempt to try to fix that? It’s a shame because I’ve always felt the 8 person, 1 booster box, 3 round setup was perfect.

    Funny that the new 30 pack play boxes still don’t work nicely with this format either 😜



  • First and foremost, I’m sorry you’ll be coming around here less :( You’re an amazing contributor and wish you all the best.

    This is an amazing post and I could not sign off any more on everything you’ve written here. I’ve felt similarly for a long time and you’ve articulated the exact same sentiments.

    I have a visceral negative reaction when I look at UB cards or think about playing games with them.

    I just simply do not want to sit across the table from all of these pop culture references or kids shows or even the crazy card frame treatments that aren’t even legible. It’s become a different game entirely and this is really the crux of it for me too.

    Agreed on all of the power creep feelings too. To add on a bit, it has seemed to me that Wizards has undergone an intense campaign to do away with bad topdecks. Every draw needs to “feel good,” and ripping a Llanowar Elf on turn 9 or land after land “doesn’t feel good.” No Bad Topdecks has meant that every card has to be relevant early and late, which is why I think we see Kicker and its variants so much, or DFC lands more and more, or cheap cards with expensive activated abilities, or abilities that can be played after you cast the card, or just straight up two cards jammed into one all the time.

    Thank you for being such a wonderful person and for being here ❤️ I hope you find something better and even more so that we see you around still!