• 0 Posts
  • 89 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 2nd, 2025

help-circle



  • I clearly stated my point. Killing someone who kills a lot of other people is murder. But it being murder isn’t evidence it’s wrong. You dismissed that without addressing it.

    You’ve never said one thing about why you think it’s wrong, other than that it’s murder. I figured you were a hardcore deontologist. What is there to discuss? It breaks the law and is therefore evil from that point of view.

    I asked for more info on why, you refused. What do you think I am to talk about here? Am I meant to guess your thoughts and argue with that?





  • I never claimed they were or weren’t, nor have I argued that they were good or bad. I was just pointing out a technicality, just as you were.

    It’s murder to shoot a dictator. It’s not murder to gun down unarmed protesters. “Murder” does not carry much moral weight, in my opinion. It just means you killed someone the state didn’t want killed, or in a way they don’t permit.

    Like when you cancel the medical coverage of people with cancer, or string the ill along with exhaustive paperwork hoping they die before you have to pay out. Not murder.